4-star hotels in Shelter Island, New York

Savings up to 60% Off!

Special Rates Available Call 855-516-1090



Topping Rose House

One Bridgehampton - Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton NY - 11932

(855) 516-1090

9.11 miles

Rating - Topping Rose House

Located In Bridgehampton, This Hotel Features A Farm-To-Table Restaurant Sourced From Its Own On-Site Farm. Guests Are Welcome Use The Property'S Complimentary House Vehicles, Provided By Lexus.A Flat-Screen Tv, An Ipad, And A Minibar Are Featured In Each Room At Topping Rose House, Which Also Provides Luxury Bathrobes And Frette Linens For Its Guests. A Sitting Area Is Included And The En Suite Bathroom Comes With A Hairdryer.A Spa, An Outdoor Heated Pool And A Fitness Centre Are All Featured On-Site At Topping Rose House. Guests Can Marvel At The Hotel'S Curated Art Collection, Or Stay Connected With Free Wifi Access. A Complimentary Shuttle To The Beach And Private Beach Passes Are Also Offered.The On-Site Restaurant Offers Locally Sourced Ingredients And Products From The Hotel'S Own One Acre Farm. Breakfast, Lunch And Dinner Are Served Daily. The Beach Is Just 4 Km From The Hotel. East Hampton Airport Is 6 Km Away.

Read more
A Butler's Manor

244 North Main Street, Southampton NY - 11968

(855) 516-1090

12.68 miles

Rating - A Butler's Manor

Boasting A Seasonal Outdoor Swimming Pool And A Garden, A Butlers Manor Is Situated In Southampton And Is 1.5 Km From Agawam Park. Featuring A Concierge Service, This Property Also Provides Guests With A Terrace. Both Free Wifi And Private Parking Are Available On Site.All Air-Conditioned Units At The Bed And Breakfast Come With A Shower, Free Toiletries, A Flat-Screen Tv With Cable Channels And Dvd Player. A Butlers Manor Provides Certain Units With Pool Views, And Rooms Are Fitted With A Private Bathroom. All Rooms Include A Desk.An American Breakfast Is Available Each Morning At The Property.

Read more
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

290 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk NY - 11954

(855) 516-1090

17.18 miles

Rating - Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

With Direct Beach Access, A Spa, A Restaurant And Free Wi-Fi, The Non-Smoking Gurney'S Inn Resort And Spa Wows Guests On Montauk, And Is Located Minutes From Shopping And Dining. The Low-Rise Gurney'S Inn Is A Non-Smoking Property With A Variety Of Floor Plans For Its 109 Rooms And Suites. The Modern Rooms Include Free Wi-Fi, Flat-Panel Tvs And Mp3-Player Docks, And Some Have Private Terraces, Balconies Or Kitchenettes. After Burning Calories In The Fitness Center Or The Indoor Saltwater Pool, Relax With A Treatment At The Spa And Soothe Sore Muscles In The Hot Tub And Sauna. Two Restaurants And A Bakery Satisfy Appetites, And Room Service Is Available. Other Amenities Include Laundry Service, A Concierge And Business Services. Parking Is Free. Located On Long Island'S South Fork, Gurney'S Inn Is Less Than Three Miles From The Shopping And Dining District In Montauk. The Train Station And Block Island Ferry Are About 10 Minutes Away, And Guests Can Survey The View From The Montauk Point Lighthouse, 15 Minutes East. Nearby Activities Include Horseback Riding, Fishing And Golfing At Montauk Downs, And Surfers Can Head To Ditch Plains Beach, Four-And-A-Half Miles Away. Long Island Macarthur Airport Is 64 Miles Away, And Laguardia Airport Is 111 Miles Away.

Read more
Copper Beech Inn

46 Main Street, Ivoryton CT - 6442

(855) 516-1090

20.09 miles

Rating - Copper Beech Inn

Offering Easy Access To The Coastal Town Of Mystic And Luxurious Rooms That Feature Period Antiques And Designer Furnishings, The Non-Smoking Copper Beech Inn Is Also Just Eight Miles From Long Island Sound Beaches. The Three-Story Non-Smoking Inn Comprises Three Buildings And Has 22 Rooms And Suites Attractively Furnished With Period Antiques And Equipped With Premium Cable Tv, Cd Players, Robes And Designer Toiletries. Some Have Cathedral Ceilings, Four-Poster Beds And Jetted Tubs For Two. The Inn'S Restaurant Serves Creative Cuisine Crafted With Farm-Fresh Ingredients And Has A 5,000-Bottle Wine List. Mornings Begin With A Complimentary Breakfast Buffet. Parking Is Free. The Inn Is Located Three Miles From Essex Village And The Connecticut River Museum. It'S Eight Miles West Of Old Saybrook And 12 Miles From Hammonassett Beach State Park In Madison. Gillette Castle In East Haddam Is 15 Miles Away, And It'S A 20-Minute Drive To The Designer Outlets At Clinton Crossings. Tweed New Haven Regional Airport Is 30 Miles Away.

Read more
Madison Beach Hotel

94 West Wharf Road, Madison CT - 6443

(855) 516-1090

20.73 miles

Rating - Madison Beach Hotel

Free Wi-Fi And A Private Beach Open All Year Long On Long Island Sound Combine For A Relaxing Stay At The Non-Smoking Madison Beach Hotel Curio Collection By Hilton. The Non-Smoking Four-Story Madison Beach Hotel Has 32 Upscale Rooms With Furnished Balconies Overlooking Long Island Sound. Rooms Come With Mini-Fridges, Free Wi-Fi, Mp3 Docks, And Flat-Panel Tvs. There'S On-Site Dining And A Bar, As Well As A Fitness Room, Spa, Staffed Business Center And A Concierge. Dogs Up To 75 Pounds Are Allowed For A Fee. Parking Is Free. The Hotel Is Three Miles Southwest Of The Charming Downtown Of Madison. The Madison Shore Line East Train Station Is One Mile Northeast, And Hammonasset Beach State Park Is Three Miles Away. The Hotel Is 18 Miles East Of Tweed New Haven Regional Airport And 55 Miles South Of Bradley International Airport. Priceline Guests Make Their Way To The This Top-Rated Waterfront Property To Enjoy Indulgent Spa Services And A Private Beach On Long Island Sound.

Read more
Topping Rose House

One Bridgehampton - Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton, NY - 11932

9.11 miles

Rating - Topping Rose House

Located In Bridgehampton, This Hotel Features A Farm-To-Table Restaurant Sourced From Its Own On-Site Farm. Guests Are Welcome Use The Property'S Complimentary House Vehicles, Provided By Lexus.A Flat...

Read more
A Butler's Manor

244 North Main Street, Southampton, NY - 11968

12.68 miles

Rating - A Butler's Manor

Boasting A Seasonal Outdoor Swimming Pool And A Garden, A Butlers Manor Is Situated In Southampton And Is 1.5 Km From Agawam Park. Featuring A Concierge Service, This Property Also Provides Guests Wit...

Read more
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

290 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY - 11954

17.18 miles

Rating - Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

With Direct Beach Access, A Spa, A Restaurant And Free Wi-Fi, The Non-Smoking Gurney'S Inn Resort And Spa Wows Guests On Montauk, And Is Located Minutes From Shopping And Dining. The Low-Rise Gurney'S...

Read more
Copper Beech Inn

46 Main Street, Ivoryton, CT - 6442

20.09 miles

Rating - Copper Beech Inn

Offering Easy Access To The Coastal Town Of Mystic And Luxurious Rooms That Feature Period Antiques And Designer Furnishings, The Non-Smoking Copper Beech Inn Is Also Just Eight Miles From Long Island...

Read more
Madison Beach Hotel

94 West Wharf Road, Madison, CT - 6443

20.73 miles

Rating - Madison Beach Hotel

Free Wi-Fi And A Private Beach Open All Year Long On Long Island Sound Combine For A Relaxing Stay At The Non-Smoking Madison Beach Hotel Curio Collection By Hilton. The Non-Smoking Four-Story Madison...

Read more

Map of 4-star hotels in Shelter Island

View all Shelter Island, New York hotels, motels, lodging and attractions on Shelter Island, New York location map.


Weather Forecast for Shelter Island, New York

If you planning to travel to Shelter Island, New York, here is your 6-day travel weather forecast to make sure you have all the essentials needed during your stay. Start your day when the sunrises at 11:41 AM. The temperature feels like 55.65 with a humidity level of 56 so dress accordingly. Cloud coverage is 13 percent with visibility at 14.9 percent. Today’s UV index is 0, don’t forget the sunscreen if you need it! Today’s winds are traveling northwest at a speed of 12 MPH. At the end of the day don’t miss the sunset at 9:28 PM.


Fahrenheit / Celsius
Monday 11/18
Few clouds

Monday 11/18 Weather forecast for Shelter Island, New York, Few clouds
57°F
High: 62°F
Low: 46°F
Precipitation: 0%
Today 11/19
Few clouds

Tuesday 11/19 Weather forecast for Shelter Island, New York, Few clouds
52°F
High: 57°F
Low: 46°F
Precipitation: 0%
Wednesday 11/20
Broken clouds

Wednesday 11/20 Weather forecast for Shelter Island, New York, Broken clouds
52°F
High: 57°F
Low: 50°F
Precipitation: 30%
Thursday 11/21
Heavy rain

Thursday 11/21 Weather forecast for Shelter Island, New York, Heavy rain
52°F
High: 59°F
Low: 43°F
Precipitation: 95%
Friday 11/22
Light rain

Friday 11/22 Weather forecast for Shelter Island, New York, Light rain
46°F
High: 50°F
Low: 42°F
Precipitation: 85%
Saturday 11/23
Light shower rain

Saturday 11/23 Weather forecast for Shelter Island, New York, Light shower rain
47°F
High: 53°F
Low: 47°F
Precipitation: 55%

Loading...